BedInABox vs. Tempur-Pedic Comparison Reviews

BedInABox vs. Tempur-Pedic: which one of these two brands can give you the bed-in-a-box mattress with the highest quality? BedInABox and Tempur-Pedic are two of the most popular trendsetters when it comes to reliable vacuum sealed mattresses in a box. So, this comparison article will help you find out which one can withstand the test of time.

BedInABox Mattress

  •  At a glance: Unique and affordable options 
  • Headline: BedInABox is no doubt the original company that started the “bed in a box” trend. The company also prides itself for offering 100% made in the USA mattresses with a long warranty period and trial nights.

Tempur-Pedic Mattress

  •  At a glance: More premium options 
  • Headline: Tempur-Pedic has been known for years as one of the leading names in the industry that offers mattresses in a box.
$300 in Free Accessories+$300 Instant Credit

Best Tempur-Pedic Deal in 2020

Purchase any Tempur-Pedic non-closeout mattress + foundation or TEMPUR-Ergo power base and get $300 in free accessories of your choice ( regular MSRP applies)

More Less
Claim This Deal

Quick Synopsis:

Before we dive into the detailed part, let’s take a look at this comprehensive comparison between the two mattress brands:

Quick Comparison

Durability – If you’re searching for mattresses that can last for several years, a BedInABox mattress can be a more reliable option. Many customers compliment the brand for making mattresses that can last for more than 7 years.

Firmness – When it comes to firmness, most of the users preferred Tempur-Pedic as it provides the “just right” firmness and support. Despite having many loyal customers, some users complain about the BedInABox mattress for being too firm.

Support – Having a good night’s sleep is essential for us to be more functional without feeling any pain in our body. Some sleepers wake up feeling very tired because their mattress doesn’t support their body, well. When it comes to supportiveness, Tempur-Pedic can provide a more customized support overtime compared to BedInABox.

BedInABox Mattress

Best For:

  • Customers who are looking for affordable mattresses
  • Customers who want many options when it comes to mattresses
  • Hot sleepers who seek for a comfortable and cooler sleep at night
  • People who want gel-infused memory foam with independent coil spring technology
  • Its motion isolation feature makes it perfect for light sleepers
  • Relieves body and joint pain

Comfort and Support Layers

Having a full eight to ten hours of sleep will make us more attentive and energetic. Thus, it is important to find the best mattress in the market not only to have a comfortable bed but also to avoid regret. The Tranquillium mattress is one of the most popular mattresses retailed by BedInABox. This mattress offers many features that you might like as a customer who seeks comfort and support.

This mattress is specially constructed with Soft Tencel top cover and CoolRest gel foam technology. With the 420 gram circular knit Tencel cover, you’ll feel cooler every night while it absorbs moisture. Tencel is known for being eco-friendly and safe for every skin since it is combined with a sleep grey border fabric. Thus, it also feels good to your skin which allows the cover alone to bring luxurious comfort for all sleepers. Meanwhile, its 3 inches CoolRest gel foam contours easily to your body and give support. It is also designed with an open-cell structure to allow better airflow, so the mattress can feel cooler. At the same time, it helps relieve muscle/body pains to feel rejuvenated when you wake up.

Edge Support

Focusing on this aspect, we can say that BedInABox mattress is a little on the downside. BedInABoxTranquillium has a combination of comfort layer, transition layer, and a support layer. However, the mattress’ layers of CoolRest, Pluralux, and Sure Align foams are not enough to provide enough edge support. Thus, it’s not the best option when sleeping near or sitting on the edge of the bed.

Tempur-Pedic Mattress

Best For:

  • Its cooling technology can provide comfortable sleep for all types of sleepers
  • Contours to your body easily and relieves muscle pain
  • Provides enough edge support to make your sleep comfortable all night
  • Hybrid and memory foam lovers
  • Can last for several years


Like the Tranquilim mattress, Tempur-Contour Elite Standard is also constructed with different layers. These are carefully selected materials that allow the mattress to provide a better sleep experience. Like the Tranquilim from BedInABox, this mattress also consists of three foam layers. These layers include the comfort layer, support layer, and base layer that provide different benefits to a wide range of users. But what the Tempur-Contour Elite Standard has that don’t is a cooling cover which keeps its layers in one piece. Its comfort layer is made Tempur-HD material, and like Tranquilim, this mattress also gives confirming support. ItsPureCool infused material also has a firmer feel to keep your body from sinking too deep. Its support layer that’s formulated from Tempur material helps distribute body weight across the mattress to avoid body pains. For its last layer, it’s constructed not only to serve as a base layer. It also helps sleepers to have a cooler sleep, with its heat transfer control which disperses heat from the mattress.


If you seek mattresses around $1,500 or less but with quality materials, you can find it in BedInABox. The Tranquilim Queen Size mattress costs $1,299.00 while its Split California King costs up only to $2,098.00. Meanwhile, the TEMPUR-Contour Elite mattress costs $2,309.30 for a Queen Size while their Split California King Size costs $3,918.60. Evidently, these numbers are enough to tell you which one is more ideal for budget seekers who don’t have a budget higher than $3,000. Tempur-pedic may be expensive but we can assure you that their products are made with high-quality materials.


Before you buy any product, you should always know each brand’s difference whenever you’re comparing them. Both products are available in different sizes. But when it comes to affordability, BedInABox is the more budget-friendly option than Tempur-Pedic. The two products that we just compare may have similarities starting from the construction, supportiveness, firmness and cooling system in their mattresses. However, these two brands have different expertise. BedInABox is the original brand that sells bed-in-a-box mattress but Tempur-Pedic seems to excel with the best memory foams in the market. BedInABox also focuses on more on a very limited list of memory foams and hybrid mattresses. On the other hand, Tempur-Pedic offers more variants that are considered as premium mattresses. For most of the Tempur-Pedic customers, it is fine to spend more as long as the mattress can last for years. When it comes to firmness most sleepers say that Tempur-Pedic is a little firm but it gradually softens in use. Whereas BedInABox can be too firm for some but its durability is worth investing in.


Are you done deciding which the best brand to pick is? Don’t worry because we’ll help you make the final decision by answering these questions.

How cool do you want your mattress to be?

BedInABox has advanced gel-infused memory foam and has an open cell structure for mattresses to be breathable and reduce heat. It’s also durable but if you want a premium version that has more cooling layers, we recommend the Contour Elite Standard. Tempur-Pedic’s multiple cooling layers make the mattress more comfortable to sleep on especially during hot nights.

How much are you willing to spend on a mattress?

Both brands offer great mattresses but BedInABox is obviously the more budget-friendly option. But if you’re willing to spend more for a more luxurious mattress, opt for Tempur-Pedic.

$300 in Free Accessories+$300 Instant Credit

Best Tempur-Pedic Deal in 2020

Purchase any Tempur-Pedic non-closeout mattress + foundation or TEMPUR-Ergo power base and get $300 in free accessories of your choice ( regular MSRP applies)

More Less
Claim This Deal

I am Linda Jones 26, editor of Matress1000. Our mission is to help people sleep better.