Best Crib Mattress Product Reviews 2022

Is it your first to buy a crib mattress? Whether it is your first-time or not, buying the best crib mattress comes should be done wisely. After all, you wouldn’t want your baby to stay awake all night since you will not get any sleep either. Besides, a poor mattress can either cause body pain to your baby just like regular mattresses on adults or allergy. To help your baby get the rest they need to grow stronger, healthier, and wiser, choose the best crib mattress. So, check out our prepared points to consider when buying one and our top 5 crib mattresses.

5 Best Crib Mattress Product Reviews 2022

#1. Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

When it comes to providing the best solution to improve the sleep of your baby, never forget the mattress. As the Editor’s Choice, Newton crib mattress is designed with a breathable technology which allows air to pass through it. This reduces the risk of suffocation and rebreathing of carbon dioxide even if your baby rolls a lot in sleep. With its temperature regulating feature, your baby can also sleep better without sweating a lot. In case of accidents, you can easily remove its recyclable cover and wash it to use it again. Specially designed for infants and toddlers, this mattress provides a longer lifespan to offer your baby so much comfort.


  • Weighs 11 pounds with 52 x 28 x 5.5 inches product dimension
  • 3D cloud spacer mattress cover made from 100% polyester that is hypoallergenic
  • 2 stages of design can last all throughout the toddlers’ years
  • Wovenaire core constructed using safe and food grade polymer materials
  • 100% breathable allows babies to breathe properly through the mattress
  • 100% washable helps babies enjoy a clean sleeping environment every night
  • 100% recyclable as it is constructed without any foam, springs, latex, or glue
  • Temperature regulator prevents it overheating and eliminates sweating to improve your baby’s sleep

For those parents/guardians who are worried about their babies that sleep on their face, we recommend this mattress. Since it has great ventilation, babies can sleep all night even with their face right on the mattress without suffocating. For sweating issues, this is also a great solution so both the babies and adults can enjoy an undisturbed sleep.


  • Prevents suffocation with its breathable feature
  • Enclosed by a removable and washable mattress cover
  • GreenGuard Gold Certified to ensure your baby’s safety with low VOCs
  • Fits in all baby cribs with a standard size


  • The odor of the polymer material only dissipate after washing it a few times
  • Some babies still get allergic reactions from its materials

#2. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress

Are you looking for a crib mattress that is 100% made in the USA? In that case, then this might the one you need for your baby. Whether you got an infant or a toddler, this mattress can offer great comfort to your little bundle of joy. Designed by a brand that specializes on premium sleep products for baby and child, this Moonlight Slumber product is a must-have. Little Dreamer offers the peace of mind that with its GreenGuard Gold Certified foam that is free from harmful chemicals. Its SafeSewn side stitched seams protect the mattress against dust and bed bugs. Moreover, its fabric cover provides a hypoallergenic layer of protection.


  • Weighs 10.5 pounds with 27.5 x 5 x 52 inches product dimension
  • Dual-sided sleep system provides the ideal firmness that is needed by infants and toddlers
  • Extra firm plant-based foam is specifically designed for infants
  • Soft and plush foam is designed for toddlers
  • Third-Party tested “all foam” provides a safe and premium quality of mattress
  • SafeSewn side stitched seams prevent pesky bed bugs and dust from penetrating the mattress
  • Medical grade stretch knit fabric offers a durable, water-resistant, and odor-resistant cover
  • Woven fire barrier is developed without any fire-resistant chemical
  • GreenGuard Gold Certified just like other Moonlight Slumber mattresses proves its quality

For an affordable crib mattress, this one is sure a handy product to have for those little bundles of joy. Made from the highest quality of non-toxic materials, we like that it doesn’t leave a toxic scent in the room. Most importantly, this is designed with advanced health and safety features which is really impressive.


  • Hypoallergenic materials prevent the intrusion of nasty bed bugs
  • Water, stain, dust, and odor resistant
  • Easy to clean and dry to ensure your baby’s safety
  • 100% made in the USA which guarantees its quality


  • The mattress cover is quite loose and some seams stick out
  • Prone to a lot of wrinkles which can be noticed all over it

#3. Safety 1stHeavenly Dreams White Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress

As a GreenGuard Gold Certified, this Safety 1stmeets the standards to provide a crib mattress with low chemical emissions. Heavenly Dreams mattress is designed to provide one of the safest sleeping environments for babies. Enclosed in a water-proof mattress cover, it is filled with high-density thermo-banded core which maintains its firm support. Furthermore, its cover can resist stains, tear, mildew, and odor which make it more worth it safer for your baby. This is thanks to its quality cover that is made from laminated vinyl with polypropylene. In case you’re worrying too much about its online, don’t worry since it fits on standard cribs and beds for toddlers.


  • Weighs 7.5 pounds with 52.5 x 27.5 x 5.5 inches product dimension
  • Designed to fit on toddler beds and standard crib with 28⅝ x 53 inches internal dimension
  • High-density core with thermo-bonded fiber gives it a firm support level
  • 5 inches profile of extra firm mattress with advanced thermo- bonded filling made from polyester
  • Built for to hold up to 50 pounds for optimal use of newborns and toddlers
  • Water-proof outer mattress cover made from 100% vinyl laminated with polypropylene can be wiped cleaned without a hassle
  • Available in White, Pink, and Blue mattress colors to match your baby’s bedroom theme or color

We find this firm enough for newborns which is an important factor to consider when buying a crib mattress. It is one of the most recommended brands for toddler mattresses which is a plus point for Safety 1st. However, we advise customers to rotate it every 2 to 3 months to extend its lifespan.


  • Super lightweight and durable
  • Ideal for long-lasting use with water-resistant cover
  • Resistant against odor, stains, and mildew
  • GreenGuard Gold Certified and Women’s Choice Award winner
  • Free from phthalate and lead materials

  • The non-removable cover starts to crack and break off over time
  • Sagging occurs after a few months of use


#4. Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress or Toddler Bed Mattress

Built with a simple promise, this Milliard aims to provide the best crib mattress specifically for toddlers. Ideal for providing a balance of comfort and support, you can count on this brand to take care of your baby’s sleep. This crib mattress comes with CertPUR-US Certified memory foam that conforms to toddlers’ delicate body. It also has 32 pounds and 28 D density with a medium-firm feel. For additional support, the mattress is enclosed by a thick polyester cover that improves its durability. Also, this prevents toddlers from sinking deep and being suffocated. At the same time, it blocks dust mites, molds, bacteria, and allergens with its hypoallergenic properties.


  • Weighs 11.7 pounds with 52 x 27.5 x 5.5 inches product dimension
  • 5 inches profile filled with high-grade memory foam allows it to provide an ultimate comfort to your baby
  • Waterproof mattress cover can be removed for a hassle-free cleaning with just a few wipes
  • Unique Milliard technology helps increase its ventilation and equal weight distribution for a more peaceful sleep
  • Fire-resistant backside encasement protects it without using any chemical


  • Designed to be naturally antimicrobial
  • Ideal for babies who suffer from allergic reactions and asthma attacks
  • Prevents dust mites, allergens, bacteria, and molds
  • Provides therapeutic and orthopedic support for babies


  • The waterproof mattress cover can be very noisy with every movement
  • Not machine washable
  • Some needs airing to dissipate its smell

#5. Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress

Eco Classica III from Colgate is an eco-friendly crib mattress filled by body contouring memory foam. It is encased in an organic fabric cover that is made from cotton to prevent triggering allergic reactions on babies. Instead of using too much chemicals, this mattress is made with certified organic materials and sustainable plant oils. Its waterproof and food grade backing up cover protects the foam from accidents and spills together with is fire-resistant flammability barrier. Furthermore, it guarantees snug fit sheets so your baby can roll on sleep without losing the covers.


  • Weighs 6.56 pounds with 51.7 x 27.5 x 6 inches product dimension
  • 6 inches profile filled with eco-friendly foam infused with sustainable plant oils to replace harmful chemicals the usually trigger allergic reactions
  • Extra-firm side provides enough firmness to support infants’ growth development
  • Less-firm side provides the comfort that toddlers love
  • Certified organic cotton cover provides an ultra-soft feel that is water-resistant to keep your baby dry and comfortable in sleep


  • 100% handcrafted in the USA by Colgate
  • Designed to last throughout babies infant and toddler years
  • Constructed without the use of any fire-retardant chemical
  • CPSIA compliant with complete requirements
  • GreenGuard Gold and CertiPUR-US Certified


  • Doesn’t provide optimal edge support
  • Prone to stains
  • Some have its seam sticking out near the corner

Points to Consider Before Buying Crib Mattresses

We all know that having a baby means welcoming new responsibilities whether it is your first-time or not. Apparently, getting a crib mattress is part of that if you want to give your little angel a good sleep. Besides, babies need all the sleep they can have aside from their daily dose of love, care, and breast milk. However, buying a crib mattress is not as simple as buying a walker.

If you are one of those meticulous parents, you might even want to visit a couple of stores before deciding. To save time on deciding regarding the best crib mattress that fits the needs of your baby, read on. Here are some things to consider before you buy the best crib mattress on physical or online shops:

Type of Mattress

When it comes to crib mattresses, there are 2 types that top the market. These are the foam and innerspring mattress.

  • Foam Mattress

This is pretty popular among customers since it is generally lightweight compared with other types of crib mattresses. It is also more cost-efficient even though its size and thickness typically vary between 3 to 6 inches. In fact, there are foam mattresses that are specially designed for infants. This can help prevent suffocation, and SIDS or Sudden Infant Death Syndrome which are sometimes caused by poor mattresses.

However, the American Academy of Pediatrics advises customers to avoid buying mattress toppers that are made from memory foams. This is because memory foams usually form indentations of the baby’s head which could lead to suffocation.

  • Innerspring Mattress

Obviously, this is the type of mattress that is filled with springs or coils. At the same time, its coils are surrounded by layers of foam or padding to eliminate its poking feeling. Thus, it is usually firmer and heavier compared with foam mattresses due to its steel coils. It is also stronger so you can expect it to last longer.


According to the CSPC, the standard size of a crib mattress should be at least 27.25 x 51.25 inches. Also, its thickness should not exceed 6 inches to ensure your baby’s comfort. If you already have a crib ready for your baby, you better make sure that get its precise size. This way, you can find the best crib mattress with the right size faster.

Just like in buying regular mattresses for your kids and adults, it should not be too big or too small. Its size should be just enough without leaving gaps between the mattress and the crib. In case you can’t find a mattress that fits perfectly in the crib, the gap should not exceed 1 inch.


Just as a crib mattress’ size may differ, its weight may range from around 7 to 8 pounds. However, some crib mattresses may also weigh as heavy as 20 pound which can be made from polyurethane foam. Those innerspring crib mattresses can weigh up to 30 pounds.


Aside from the mentioned points above, you should also consider its cover. This is the first layer of protection that your baby can benefit from the crib mattress. The comfort of your baby also relies on the cover since it is the first layer that will endure accidents/spills. Thus, it should be removable and washable so you can clean it easily on regular basis. As much as possible, buy a crib mattress with a hypoallergenic cover too.


Are you a picky customer? If yes, then that is totally fine. In fact, that might actually come in handy when it comes to buying the best crib mattress. Of course, there are lots of options to choose from that are manufactured by different brands. It size and thickness varies so you better take a close look in the products’ description, features, and specifications. At the same time, its materials used also vary. The higher quality of the materials used the higher price you can expect.

But aside from the given guide above, you should also consider your baby’s welfare. Avoid mattresses that can cause or trigger allergic reactions to your baby and those that contain harmful chemicals.


I am Linda Jones 26, editor of Matress1000. Our mission is to help people sleep better.